top of page
  • Writer's pictureJosé R. Hernández

How to Evaluate the Performance of Your HOA Management Company

For an HOA, the right management company can be the linchpin in ensuring the community runs smoothly. It's a partnership that goes beyond mere service provision; it's about aligning values, delivering transparent and efficient operations, and fostering a thriving community. But how do you know if your HOA management company is delivering on its promises? In this post, we'll go through a detailed process to evaluate the performance of your HOA management company, emphasizing the indicators and methodologies that board members can use to ensure their community is getting the best service possible.

The Core Importance of Choice

The competence and effectiveness of an HOA management company can significantly impact property values, resident satisfaction, and the community's overall health. In the vast landscape of property management, not all companies are created equal, and choosing the right one is an essential, albeit complicated, decision.

HOA board members must be vigilant in assessing the HOA management company they hire, ensuring that it aligns with the HOA's goals and operates in the community's best interests.

Key Performance Indicators

Specific key performance indicators (KPIs) should be considered when evaluating an HOA management company's performance. These KPIs serve as the yardsticks against which the company's performance can be measured.

Financial Transparency

A transparent and well-managed financial system is critical for an HOA. The management company should provide regular financial reports that are clear, thorough, and easily accessible. KPIs for financial transparency include:

  • Accuracy and timeliness of financial reports

  • Open-book policies for the HOA board

  • Detailed accounting practices and systems

Communication Effectiveness

Effective communication is the bedrock of a well-functioning community. The management company should maintain open lines of communication with the HOA board, residents, and service providers. KPIs for communication include:

  • Responsiveness to queries and concerns

  • Usage of multiple communication channels (e.g., newsletters, emails, community portals)

  • Timely notification of important updates and decisions

Maintenance and Repairs

The physical maintenance of the property is a visible sign of the management company's performance. The company should ensure the timely upkeep of common areas and respond promptly to maintenance requests. KPIs for maintenance and repairs include:

  • Average response time to repair requests

  • Frequency and efficiency of scheduled maintenance

  • Track record for improving or maintaining property condition

Compliance and Legal Matters

An HOA management company must be well-versed in the community's legal requirements and governing documents. KPIs for compliance and legal matters include:

  • Number of compliance violations

  • The outcome of legal disputes

  • Clarity of communication regarding regulatory changes

Methods of Evaluation

Once the board has identified the KPIs, the next step is to employ effective evaluation methods. These should provide a comprehensive understanding of the management company's performance and highlight areas for potential improvement.

Surveys and Feedback

Conducting surveys among residents and board members can yield invaluable insights into the community's satisfaction with the management company's performance. Surveys should be designed to cover the agreed-upon KPIs and can be anonymous to encourage honest feedback.

Financial Audits

Regular audits of the HOA's finances, conducted by a third party, can assure the management company's financial activities. Audits should be thorough and cover all financial procedures and records.

Site Visits and Inspections

Board members can conduct regular site visits and inspections to assess the general tidiness and maintenance of common areas and gauge the level of engagement and responsiveness of on-site staff.

Industry Benchmarks and Best Practices

The evaluation process should also consider industry benchmarks and best practices to understand where your HOA management company stands relative to its peers. This benchmarking process allows the board to set realistic goals for the management company and track their progress over time.

Comparison with Industry Standards

By comparing the HOA's financial and operational performance with industry standards, the board can assess whether the management company is maintaining an acceptable level of service or is falling short in certain areas.

Learning from Best Practices

Studying the best practices of highly regarded management companies can help the board identify opportunities for improvement within their organization and, in turn, provide constructive feedback to the management company.


Evaluating the performance of your HOA management company is not just a prudent practice — it's an imperative one. A reliable management company can enhance the value of your community, foster harmonious resident relations, and ensure the seamless operation of various community services.

HOA board members can maintain robust oversight of their management company by establishing clear KPIs, using effective evaluation methods, and benchmarking against industry standards. This proactive approach safeguards the community's interests and promotes continuous improvement within the management company itself.

In sum, the evaluation process is a shared responsibility. It requires commitment and involvement from the HOA board and the management company. A transparent and regular dialogue regarding performance expectations, assessment methodologies, and action plans for improvement will foster a partnership that propels the community forward.

Did I miss anything? Please let me know in the comments! Also, please subscribe to our blog to receive a notification when new articles arrive.

At Don Asher Management, we've proudly served the Central Florida community for over 70 years. As a locally-owned company with a strong understanding of the local market, we've cultivated substantial relationships with local and national contractors to provide top-quality services. We're dedicated to meeting your Property and HOA management needs with a personalized touch, combining our decades of experience and commitment to detail for unmatched service. We're confident in our ability to deliver exceptional services tailored just for you. Choose Don Asher Management - where personalized attention meets professional service.

252 views0 comments


bottom of page