DIY vs. Property Manager: Who Installs What and Who Manages Access
- José R. Hernández
- 9 minutes ago
- 5 min read
As you grow your real estate portfolio beyond a single rental property, the operational demands shift significantly. Managing one smart lock is simple; managing ten across different locations becomes a logistical challenge. The rise of property technology—smart locks, leak sensors, and cameras—offers incredible opportunities to protect your assets and increase efficiency. However, it also introduces a new question: Who should be responsible for installing, monitoring, and managing this tech?
For many investors, the decision between a DIY approach and hiring a professional property manager comes down to valuing their time versus their control. This guide provides a side-by-side comparison of these responsibilities, helping you decide which model best supports your investment goals.
Installation: The "One-Hour" Upgrade Reality
Smart home upgrades are often marketed as "easy DIY projects." While true for a single homeowner, the reality changes when you are coordinating access with tenants or managing multiple units.
The DIY Approach
If you choose to self-manage, you are the installer. This means you are responsible for purchasing the hardware, coordinating a time with the tenant to enter the property, and physically installing the devices.
Pros: You save on labor costs and have intimate knowledge of how the device was set up.
Cons: You assume all liability for installation errors. If a smart lock is installed incorrectly and a break-in occurs, or if a leak sensor isn't paired correctly to the Wi-Fi, the responsibility falls entirely on you. You also spend valuable time traveling to properties rather than analyzing your next investment.
The Property Manager Approach
A professional property manager treats technology installation as a standardized operation. They typically do not perform the physical labor themselves but coordinate with vetted vendors who specialize in these systems.
Pros: Installations are performed correctly and consistently across your portfolio. The property manager handles tenant coordination, ensuring proper notice is given before entry. They also ensure the technology integrates seamlessly with their management software.
Cons: You will pay for the vendor's labor, though this is often offset by the manager's bulk pricing or preferred vendor relationships.
Access Control: Security and Convenience
Smart locks are game-changers for rental properties, eliminating the need for physical keys. However, the true power of a smart lock lies in software management, not just its hardware.
DIY Access Management
In a DIY model, you are the administrator. You create codes for tenants, delete them upon move-out, and generate temporary codes for maintenance.
The Risk: It is easy to forget to revoke a vendor's access code after a repair is complete. If you manage multiple properties, keeping track of which code belongs to which tenant can become confusing. There is often no audit trail when a single "landlord" code is shared among multiple contractors.
Property Manager Access Management
Professional managers use enterprise-level software to manage access control.
Time-Limited Codes: When a plumber is dispatched, they receive a unique code that only works during their scheduled window. Once the job is done, the code expires automatically.
Tenant Security: Tenants receive their own private codes. When a lease ends, the system automatically revokes access, securing the property instantly without a site visit.
Audit Trails: The manager can see exactly who entered the property and when, providing crucial evidence in case of a security dispute or theft claim.
Monitoring and Alerts: The 2 AM Wake-Up Call
The most significant difference between self-management and professional management appears when things go wrong. Smart devices generate alerts—leak detected, door left ajar, low battery. Who responds to these alerts defines your quality of life as an investor.
The DIY Reality
If you self-manage, your phone is the command center.
Notification Overload: You receive every alert directly. If a leak sensor triggers at 2:00 AM on a Tuesday, you must wake up, assess the severity, and decide whether to call a plumber immediately.
Vacation Vulnerability: If you are traveling or out of cell service, critical alerts may go unnoticed for hours or days, potentially leading to catastrophic damage.
The Property Manager Solution
Property managers act as a filter and a safety net.
24/7 Monitoring: Their team or software monitors alerts around the clock. They have protocols to distinguish between a low-battery warning (scheduled maintenance) and a water leak (immediate emergency).
After-Hours Response: If a critical alert comes in overnight, the property manager dispatches an emergency vendor immediately. You read about the incident in a report the next morning, rather than dealing with it in real time.
Escalation Rules: Structured Decision Making
Technology detects problems; people solve them. The speed and efficiency of that solution depend on established escalation rules.
DIY Escalation
As a DIY landlord, every decision requires your input.
Scenario: A smart thermostat alerts you that the internal temperature has reached 85°F.
Action: You must call the tenant to see if they are home, then call HVAC companies to find one with availability, then negotiate pricing. This reactive approach is time-consuming and stressful.
Property Manager Escalation
Managers operate on pre-authorized workflows.
Scenario: The same high-temp alert is received.
Action: The system recognizes this as an "urgent HVAC failure." The manager's team immediately contacts the tenant to confirm the issue and dispatches a preferred HVAC vendor with agreed-upon pricing and service-level agreements (SLAs). The problem is often fixed before you would have even found a vendor's phone number.
Why Professional Management Wins for Growth
For investors with a single property, the DIY approach can be a manageable way to learn the ropes. However, as your portfolio grows from two to three or ten properties, the operational friction of self-management compounds.
A property manager doesn't just install a lock; they implement a security ecosystem. They don't just fix a leak; they minimize the damage through rapid, automated response protocols. By handing over the technical operations to a professional, you regain your time and mental energy to focus on what matters most: growing your investment portfolio.
Streamline your operations and protect your assets with expert support. Contact Don Asher Management today to learn how our technology-driven property management services can simplify your life and maximize your returns.
Did I miss anything? Please let me know in the comments! Also, please subscribe to our blog to receive notifications when new articles are published.
At Don Asher Management, we've proudly served the Central Florida community for over 70 years. As a locally owned company with a strong understanding of the local market, we've cultivated strong relationships with regional and national contractors to deliver top-quality services. We're dedicated to meeting your property and HOA management needs with a personalized touch, combining our decades of experience and commitment to detail to provide unmatched service. We're confident in our ability to deliver exceptional services tailored just for you. Choose Don Asher Management—where personalized attention meets professional service.
Comments