Why Do Homeowners Think HOAs Are “Bad”? Lessons for Board Members
- José R. Hernández
- Oct 9
- 6 min read
The term "HOA" can provoke strong reactions from homeowners. For many, it brings to mind stories of unreasonable rules, surprise fees, and power-hungry neighbors. While board members are volunteers working to protect community assets, a significant perception gap often exists between them and the community. Understanding why homeowners develop these negative views is the first step for any board dedicated to improving community relations and fostering a more positive environment.
This post will explore the common pain points that lead homeowners to believe HOAs are "bad." More importantly, it provides practical lessons and actionable steps board members can take to address these perceptions, rebuild trust, and transform the homeowner experience. By turning complaints into constructive feedback, you can create a community that residents are proud to call home.
1. The “Lack of Transparency” Perception
Many homeowners feel left in the dark about how their money is spent and why certain decisions are made. When budgets are approved behind closed doors or special assessments appear without clear justification, residents assume the worst. This secrecy, whether intentional or not, is a primary driver of distrust.
The Root Cause: This often stems from poor communication practices, not deliberate concealment. Board members can become busy, and they may assume that financial reports or meeting minutes are self-explanatory. They might fail to provide context, leading homeowners to fill in the blanks with suspicion.
The Lesson for Board Members: Transparency is an active process. You must proactively share information in a way that is easy for non-experts to understand.
Actionable Steps:
Publish Financial Summaries: Instead of just posting a dense budget spreadsheet, create a simple one-page summary or a pie chart showing where assessment dollars go (e.g., landscaping, insurance, reserves).
Create a “Decision Log”: After each meeting, post a brief, plain-language summary of key decisions and the rationale behind them on the community portal or website.
Host "Ask the Board" Sessions: Hold quarterly, informal Q&A sessions outside of regular board meetings. This gives residents a low-pressure environment to ask questions about finances, projects, or policies.
2. The “Inconsistent Enforcement” Complaint
A homeowner gets a violation notice for their unmowed lawn while their neighbor’s equally overgrown yard goes unaddressed. This is the classic complaint of selective or inconsistent enforcement. When rules are not applied fairly to everyone, it creates feelings of resentment and erodes the board’s credibility.
The Root Cause: Inconsistency often arises from a lack of formal procedures. A board member might verbally warn a friend, while another resident receives a formal letter for the same infraction. It can also happen when different board members have different interpretations of the rules.
The Lesson for Board Members: Consistency requires a system. A clear, documented enforcement policy that is consistently followed is your best defense against claims of favoritism.
Actionable Steps:
Adopt a Formal Enforcement Policy: Document the entire process in writing: courtesy notice, formal violation letter, opportunity for a hearing, and fine schedule. Make this policy easily accessible to all homeowners.
Use a Work Order or Violation Tracking System: Log every violation, notice, and resolution. This creates an objective record and helps ensure consistent application of the rules.
Conduct Regular Community Inspections: Have one or two designated people perform routine property inspections on a set schedule. This standardizes the process and removes individual bias.
3. The “Micromanaging Rules” Frustration
Homeowners can feel stifled by rules they perceive as overly restrictive or nonsensical, such as dictating the exact shade of beige for their curtains or prohibiting children's chalk art on sidewalks. When the board appears to focus on trivial issues, residents feel micromanaged and resentful.
The Root Cause: This perception often develops when boards enforce rules without explaining their purpose. A rule that seems silly on the surface may have a legitimate basis in preserving property values or preventing long-term maintenance issues. Without that context, it just feels controlling.
The Lesson for Board Members: Connect every rule to a tangible community benefit. If you cannot explain the "why" behind a rule, it may be time to reconsider it.
Actionable Steps:
Create a “Rule Rationale” Document: For your most-questioned rules, write a simple explanation of their purpose. For example, "The rule about storing trash cans out of sight is to prevent pest issues and maintain curb appeal for all homes."
Review and Retire Outdated Rules: Conduct an annual review of your governing documents. Are there rules that are no longer relevant or necessary? Removing obsolete regulations shows you are reasonable and adaptable.
Focus on Impact: Prioritize enforcement on violations that have a clear, negative impact on safety, property values, or community harmony. Let minor, temporary issues slide when appropriate.
4. The “Poor Communication” Problem
Vague newsletters, unannounced maintenance projects, and unanswered emails are hallmarks of poor HOA communication. When residents feel uninformed, they become anxious and frustrated. A sudden water shutoff or the appearance of construction crews without warning makes homeowners think that their lives are being disrupted without consideration.
The Root Cause: Boards often underestimate the frequency and clarity of communication needed. They might send one email and assume everyone has seen it, or use technical jargon that residents don't understand.
The Lesson for Board Members: Effective communication must be planned, consistent, and multi-channeled. Over-communicating is always better than under-communicating.
Actionable Steps:
Establish a Communication Calendar: Plan a regular cadence of updates, such as a monthly e-newsletter, weekly project updates, and quarterly financial snapshots.
Use Multiple Channels: Don’t rely solely on email. Use a community portal, website announcements, and even physical flyers or bulletin boards for important information.
Lead with the WIIFM ("What's In It For Me?"): Structure your messages around the impact on the homeowner. Instead of "The board has approved the HVAC contract," try "Good news! A new, more efficient HVAC system is being installed in the clubhouse, which will lower our utility costs and improve comfort."
5. The “Surprise Fee Increases” Shock
Nothing sours a homeowner on their HOA faster than a large, unexpected special assessment or a steep increase in annual dues. It can feel like a financial ambush, especially for those on a fixed income. This leads to the perception that the board is financially irresponsible.
The Root Cause: This shock is almost always the result of poor long-term financial planning. Boards that fail to fund reserves over time adequately are eventually forced to levy special assessments when major components (like roofs or elevators) fail.
The Lesson for Board Members: Proactive financial management and transparent forecasting are essential to prevent financial surprises and build trust in your fiscal stewardship.
Actionable Steps:
Commission and Follow a Reserve Study: A professional reserve study is a roadmap for your community's future expenses. Fund it adequately every year and communicate the plan to residents.
Forecast Potential Increases: Well in advance of the annual budget meeting, communicate the factors driving potential cost increases (e.g., "Our insurance premiums are projected to rise by 15% next year.").
Visualize the Reserves: Use charts to show homeowners the current reserve fund balance versus the fully funded goal. This visual clearly illustrates why contributions are necessary.
Putting It All Together: A 90-Day Plan to Rebuild Trust
Days 1-30: Audit and Listen. Review your current communication and enforcement policies. Send a simple survey to homeowners, asking them to identify their top three pain points.
Days 31-60: Standardize and Plan. Based on feedback, draft and adopt a formal enforcement policy and a communication calendar. Review your reserve study and create a funding plan.
Days 61-90: Communicate and Implement. Host a town hall to present your new policies and plans to the community. Explain the "why" behind them and begin executing your new communication schedule.
Conclusion
The negative perception of HOAs is often a symptom of solvable problems rooted in communication, consistency, and transparency. As a board member, you have the power to change this narrative in your community. By listening to homeowner concerns, explaining the rationale behind rules, and creating predictable systems for enforcement and finance, you can shift the dynamic from adversarial to collaborative. This proactive approach not only reduces conflict but also enhances property values and fosters a stronger sense of community for everyone. Discover how we can help you achieve your community goals.
Did I miss anything? Please let me know in the comments! Also, please subscribe to our blog to receive a notification when new articles arrive.
At Don Asher Management, we've proudly served the Central Florida community for over 70 years. As a locally-owned company with a strong understanding of the local market, we've cultivated substantial relationships with regional and national contractors to provide top-quality services. We're dedicated to meeting your property and HOA management needs with a personalized touch, combining our decades of experience and commitment to detail to provide unmatched service. We're confident in our ability to deliver exceptional services tailored just for you. Choose Don Asher Management - where personalized attention meets professional service.